The Call for a New Science
and... the New Science
OBJECTIVES:
1. Be able to discuss the theses of Bacon's New
Organon.
2. Be able to explain Bacon's critique of the four
idols of knowledge.
3. Be able to explain Bacon's critique of Aristotelian
logic and philosophy.
4. Be able to explain the primary characteristics of
knowledge for Bacon, and how those characteristics
separated his system from those of the medievals, Greeks
and Romans.
5. Be able to discuss how Galileo, Newton and the
other scientific revolutionaries of the seventeenth
century are examples of Bacon's new methodology for
acquiring knowledge.
6. Be able to explain the primary contributions of
Galileo and Newton to science, and how their world view
differed from that of their predecessors.
7. Be able to explain Galileo's interpretation of the
Bible, and his arguments as to the relationship of his
discoveries to the Church's interpretation of the
Scriptures.
8. Be able to discuss Newtonian mechanics, and
Newton's position on the role of God in the universe.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT:
from Bacon's New Organon:
"The logic now in use serves rather to fix and give
stability to the errors which have their foundation in
commonly received notions than to help the search after
truth. So it does more harm than good."
"The idols and false notions which are now in
possession of the human understanding, and have taken
deep root therein, not only so beset men's minds that
truth can hardly find entrance, but even after entrance
is obtained, they will again in the very insaturation of
the sciences meet and trouble us, unless men being
forewarned of the danger fortify themselves as far as may
be against their assaults. There are four classes of
Idols which beset men's minds. To these for distinctions
sake I have assigned names, calling the first class the
Idols of the Tribe; the second, the Idols of the Cave;
the third, Idols of the Market Place; the fourth, Idols
of the Theater."
"It is not possible to run a course aright when the
goal has not been properly placed."
"Man, being the servant and interpreter of Nature, can
do and understand so much and so much only as he has
observed in fact or in thought of the course of nature.
Beyond this he neither knows anything nor can do
anything."
"Human knowledge and human power meet in one."
On Newton:
"Nature and nature's laws lay hidden in the
night, and God said "let Newton be and there as light."
Alexander Pope
"Descartes put us on a road to truth; Newton
took us unto the end of that journey."
Voltaire
"Nearer to the gods no mortal has come."
OUTLINE
I. Francis Bacon
A. Brief bio
B. Cambridge University
i) The Aristotelian climate
C. Critic of Aristotelianism
i) what was wrong with European philosophy
a) mixture of religion and natural philosophy
b) The mind and its relationship to words, and
things
c) The need for a "chaste, holy, and legal
wedlock"
ii) method
a) analogies
b) The New Organon
i) what it is to be human
ii) what it is to be Christian
iii) Themes of the New Organon;
a) Knowledge is power
b)Separation of natural philosophy from
Theology
c) Induction
i) vs. Deduction
a) the syllogism
ii) rejection of authority
iii) Progress and cooperation
a) vs. Authority
iv)The Three kinds of minds
a) ants
b) spiders
c) honey bees
D. The New Atlantis
E. Summary
II. Bacon's philosophy in action: Galileo and
Newton
A. Galileo
i) his observations
ii) his conclusions
iii) overthrow of Ptolomaic universe
a) geocentric universe
iv) his trial and condemnation
B. Isaac Newton (1642-1727)
i) Brief Biography
ii) the counter institutions of the seventeenth
century
a) The Royal Society
b) Bacon as hero: origin of the Faculty of Arts and
Sciences
iii) 1661 entry into Cambridge University
a) The Cartesians
iv) The Plague year: 1665
a) to Woolsthorpe and the country
b) most phenomenal 18 months in human history
c) gravitation
d) laws of motion
e) differential and infinitesimal calculus
f) optics
g) thermodynamics
h) his discoveries still a secret
v) 1684: "And God said let Newton be and there was
light."
a) Halley, Wren, and Hook and the problem of
Huyghens
b) advice from Newton
c) The Philosophiae Naturalis Principia
Mathematica: 1687
d) seeing into the mind of God
vi) appraisals of Newton
a) Alexander Pope
b) Voltaire
c) "Nearer the gods no mortal has approached."
d) The Cartesian Appraisal of Newton
vii) summary: The Newtonian Revolution